Ocean Beach's destination restaurant offers inspired menus and creative cocktails in an elegant, relaxing atmosphere. The Hideaway Restaurant has a waterfront dining deck and freshly prepared daily specials.
Established in 1921, Houser's Hotel is the longest running, continually operated restaurant on Fire Island. The bar was opened after the end of prohibition in 1933. Housers Bar offers casual, bayfront dining and a full service bar.
Ice Castle Sweet Shoppe is the sweetest stop on Fire Island! Ice Castle has a large selection of delicious sweets including home made fudge, ice cream, Italian ice, iced coffee, specialty candies and more.
The Island Breeze restaurant is a classic American restaurant with great water views. Check out the Tiki Bar at the Island Breeze to watch the the best sunset views in Cherry Grove.
The Island Mermaid is a landmark destination that features waterfront dining in the center of Ocean Beach. Using the freshest ingredients for a unique and elegant dining experience. The Island Mermaid also offers catering.
At Jersey Mike’s Subs, we offer a sub above – one that’s measured in more than inches or seconds ‘til served. We carefully consider every aspect of what we do – every slice, every sandwich, every store – we provide our customers with sustenance and substance too. Open 10AM—9PM
Order ahead and pick up a Jersey Mike Sub on your way to the ferry!
Red wine vinegar and an olive oil blend. It’s how a Jersey Mike’s sub gets its exquisite zing. It’s how bites get boosted, and a great sub becomes an even better one. The Juice adds that certain something extra. An exclamation. The kind of exclamation... you can eat.
Kingston's Clam Bar has over 40 years of fresh seafood on the Bay. Kingston's has a full bar with martini and frozen drink specials.
The Kismet Inn is an icon of Fire island. Long Islanders boat over to the marina and mingle with Day Trippers and locals to have a few beers, play pool and nosh on baked clams. Located on the bay front, The Inn is jumping well into the night and serving pancakes the next morning. Marina is for Kismet Inn patrons.
Le Dock serves fresh seafood, steaks and specialty Italian dinners overlooking the Great South Bay. A tradition started in 1976 and re-established in 2019. Also enjoy the luscious cocktails and desserts.
Maguire's Bayfront Restaurant uses only the freshest garden to table ingredients. Featuring a deck overlooking the Great South Bay, Maguire's serves sunsets daily and offers numerous summer-long specials.
Mallory Square Restaurant in Sayville offers spectacular views of the bay and delicious refined american cuisine.
The Marina Bar+Grill showcases classic favorites + specials, featuring fresh, local market produce, top regional fish & seafood, as well as premium meats & poultry. From harbor-side al fresco, to the more intimate dining/cabaret room, come for a return to the classics, at Tea Dance, by the Piano, and for simple elegant dining.
Matthew's Seafood House offers fresh, traditional American style daily specials. Check out Matthew’s Catering for our fine catering menus. A unique food experience since 1974. Docking available during restaurant operating hours.
Mitsui Japanese Restaurant & Lounge serves Japanese fusion cuisine for lunch and dinner. There is a full bar and catering available. Mitsui brings in fresh fish daily, but offers far more than just sushi.
Nicky's Clam Bar is a casual restaurant and take out window in Bay Shore with daily specials. Nicky's has a full beer, liquor and wine selection with many local brews. Catering and children's menu also available.
Nicky's on the Bay has indoor and outdoor waterfront dining with beautiful water views. They offer fresh fish, live lobsters, Italian entrees, burgers and daily specials. Visit the friendly bar with delicious cocktails and extensive beer selection. Nicky's on the Bay also offers catering.
Off The Block Gourmet Kitchen & Meats is your local butcher shop and restaurant in Sayville, NY. Stop by on your way to the Cherry Grove and Pines ferries and pick up fresh food for the weekend. We prepare our menu items directly from the fresh, quality products in our own butcher case and from locally sourced in-season produce. We offer locally sourced prime, dry-aged and choice cuts, prepared foods, catering, and made-to-order sandwiches, appetizers and dinner specials.
The Pines Bistro & Martini Bar is a Continental restaurant, offering traditional favorite dishes, plus daily/seasonal specials. It is the only establishment in the Pines that offers all-season, sit-down dinner, with sophisticated cocktail lounge ambience. Be sure to make a reservation.
Pines Pizza is in the heart of the Fires Island Pines community, with our deck overlooking, and opening directly onto, Fire Island Boulevard, we’re your local Pizza & Take-Away Place. We offer salads, Grab•n•Go meals, plus all-day coffee & more, from early April to late September.
The Pizza Shack of Kismet is good for a quick slice or late night snack. Also try the ice cream and soft serve.